Unfair dismissal due to indirect sex discrimination and failure to follow correct redundancy procedure!

A mother of two children was a victim of indirect sex discrimination and unfair dismissal when she was made redundant after her contract was amended to require long-distance travel, according to an employment tribunal.

The employee was a tax specialist and was unable to travel significant distances because of childcare limitations. She informed her manager that if the contractual changes meant that her role involved travel, she would not be able to continue. She felt unable to secure childcare to enable her to leave early in the morning and return late in the evening because her husband had a demanding job which meant he was often away from home.

The employee was told that there was an expectation for her to travel following a change in organisational structure, when she was asked to head up a department which was relocating.  She suggested a compromise with her employer, stating her willingness to travel reasonable distances and meet face to face or virtually, if significant travel was required. She said that she was willing to travel reasonable distances providing she could return by 6pm for childcare. She explained that her husband was rarely available to step in to support with childcare.

The employee was put at risk of redundancy and was told that failure to comply with the demand could potentially lead to disciplinary action. Two days later she was given notice of redundancy.

The employment tribunal found that the employee was unfairly dismissed as the business had not demonstrated a fair reason for her dismissal or shown that there was a sufficient reason to enforce the need for significant travel. The employer also failed to consider any form of alternative role.  The employee was successful in her claim of indirect sex discrimination since it was not proportionate to ask her to travel significant distances in her role to achieve the business objective of “efficacy and staff morale”.

The employment tribunal found that the employee was put at a “particular disadvantage” by the requirement to travel significant distances which amounted to indirect sex discrimination.  It also determined that the employee had done the job for 10 months without complaint and had the confidence of staff, concluding that it was not “reasonably necessary to travel significant distances”.

The financial award remains to be determined.  This case reminds employers that any change of contractual terms must be reasonable and that consultation must occur to discuss potential detriment towards affected staff. If you have any questions regarding this subject, please contact us on enquiries@121hrsolutions.co.uk.

Privacy Policy

 

 

Powered by The Logic of Eight - Creative Media