‘Old fossil’ comment resulted in an award of £3.1m for age discrimination

A senior executive at a FTSE 250 firm was a victim of age discrimination, unfair dismissal and victimisation after being dismissed and replaced with a younger employee. The claimant had been global business unit president of a metal engineering and technology firm since 2014 and was 58 when he was dismissed.  The Tribunal’s findings included an observation that, had the claimant been in his forties, it is likely he would have been treated more favourably.

The issue began when the CEO addressed the firm’s senior managers, making the comment: “These millennials will never stop until they have my job and you older guys had better get used to it.” Following that meeting, the claimant noted that the CEO referred to him as an “old fossil” and accused him of not understanding millennials. Interestingly, the tribunal noted that the claimant had previously pushed for young engineers to be recruited straight from college in every plant around the world due to the fact a number of key managers were expected to retire in the next five years, evidencing his awareness of the need to ensure effective succession planning!

The claimant’s role was moved from the US to the UK and he relocated, incurring relocation costs of over £200,000 which were not reimbursed and at the same time, the business had engaged an executive search agency to find a replacement for the claimant. Soon after, the claimant was placed on garden leave for six months. The employer did not explore any alternatives to dismissal, such as redeployment and he was dismissed on the basis of a restructuring exercise in the UK. 

The tribunal found that the dismissal fell outside of the range of reasonable responses and using a hypothetical comparator, it found that had the claimant had been in his forties, he would have experienced “more patient treatment” and a more in-depth process of consultation. 

The employer has been told to pay out a total of £3,171,723 – one of the largest awards granted by an employment tribunal, consisting of £1.38m for financial losses, £20,000 for injury to feelings and a 7.5% Acas uplift. There was also an award for relocation and the sale of the claimant’s US home.

Clearly this is a complex case and the events reported occurred over a period of several years. Ill-advised comments relating to age – or any other protected characteristic – can result in employees building a case for discrimination. Managers should be trained in equality and diversity and organisational culture must reflect appropriate treatment of all employees. If you feel that your managers require additional support or training in equality and diversity please contact us at enquiries@121hrsolutions.co.uk.

Privacy Policy

 

 

Powered by The Logic of Eight - Creative Media