You are “sour and bitter” could amount to sex discrimination!

An employee who was made redundant after a decade of service pursued a claim for discrimination after her manager made inappropriate remarks and described her as a “sour and bitter individual” in an email.

Her claims were initially dismissed by the employment tribunal. However, the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) ruled that significant procedural failings in the original hearing, including relying too heavily on evidence from the respondent, justified a retrial.

The claimant focused on what she described as a longstanding and strained working relationship with her direct line manager which had broken down entirely. She “made it clear” she did not want him supervising her and threatened to raise a grievance if the arrangement was enforced.

Her claims included allegations of a series of derogatory remarks, including telling her that her top was “revolting” and suggesting she “see a psychiatrist” due to “serious psychological problems.”

The tribunal heard that she kept a detailed log of incidents including an email in which he referred to her as a “sour and bitter individual.”

The claimant argued that this phrase, coupled with his use of “that woman,” reflected discriminatory attitudes towards her sex. In her appeal, she told the panel “While definitely offensive, I would like to ask the tribunal to consider whether it is related to sex, bearing in mind that he also referred to me as ‘that woman.’”

The EAT has now ordered a retrial before a different tribunal panel, which will reconsider the facts and decide whether the comments and other actions amounted to discrimination, harassment, or victimisation.

This case underlines the importance of addressing potential sexism in workplace interactions and the need for thorough, unbiased investigations when employees raise complaints of discrimination, sexual harassment or mistreatment. If you would like more information on how 121 HR Solutions can assist your business, contact us at enquiries@121hrsolutions.co.uk and we can discuss.

Privacy Policy

 

 

Powered by The Logic of Eight - Creative Media