Unfair dismissal could have been avoided if the correct procedure had been followed!
A bus driver who allegedly said a colleague with PTSD who was off sick with a migraine was “just playing at it” was unfairly dismissed, a tribunal has ruled. The employee had already been issued with a final written warning for misconduct, and was dismissed after the allegations of bullying and harassment were made against her, when she was reported to have played down a colleague’s PTSD symptoms.
However, the judge concluded that the dismissal was procedurally unfair as the employee was not provided with copies of relevant documents during the disciplinary process. This failure resulted in the employee being able to challenge the claims made against her. The ACAS Code of Practice on Disciplinary and Grievance procedures includes the requirement to “inform the employee of the problem and this omission made the disciplinary procedurally unfair.
Ironically, the tribunal ruled that the compensatory award should be reduced by 90% as the claimant was likely to have been dismissed anyway had the respondent followed a reasonable procedure as a result of the evidence against her.
It is important that fairness is shown during hearings and that employees are provided with all available evidence in advance of a disciplinary hearing. In this case, the employer incurred the considerable cost of defending a tribunal which may never have come to court if the correct process had been followed.
121 HR Solutions provides training on managing investigation and disciplinary procedures. For further information on our range of training, click here.

