William Hill ordered to pay £70,000 after tribunal finds executive was unfairly dismissed
A former senior employee at William Hill has been awarded nearly £70,000 after an employment tribunal ruled that he was unfairly dismissed following allegations of sexual harassment. The tribunal found significant flaws in how the investigation was handled, particularly regarding the evidence used to justify the dismissal.
The employee lost his job without notice after being accused of inappropriate conduct toward a female colleague during a company event at a pub. The allegations included claims that he touched the colleague inappropriately and placed his fingers in her mouth. Although the incident was reported to the police, no criminal charges were brought due to lack of evidence, including CCTV footage.
The employment tribunal was critical of William Hill’s internal investigation, noting that efforts to obtain available CCTV footage were lacking and that the investigative process relied heavily on limited and vague witness statements. The judge pointed to a failure to gather comprehensive evidence or interview witnesses impartially remarking that the company only appeared to gather enough information to support the complainant’s version of events, without exploring whether the employee could be exonerated. This approach led to an unfair dismissal. Only one witness supported the complainant’s account directly, while others testified only that she appeared upset afterward. Notably, the tribunal found that the investigator’s interview notes lacked important contextual details, such as timelines and the positioning of those present.
The employee denied the allegations and described his interactions as friendly. He also raised concerns about the impartiality of the investigation and the limited scope of the inquiry—particularly the failure to obtain bar CCTV or to provide him access to company policies. The tribunal concluded that given the potential career damage from a gross misconduct finding, the employer should have conducted a far more rigorous and impartial investigation.
This case reinforces the importance of thorough and unbiased workplace investigations, particularly when serious allegations are involved and the need for proper training for those handling disciplinary matters to ensure that fair procedures are followed throughout the process.
The claims of unfair dismissal were upheld, along with his entitlement to redundancy pay, notice, and accrued holiday amounting to an award of £68,065.29.
Should you require an impartial and thorough investigation process to be undertaken in your business, contact 121 HR Solutions at enquiries@121hrsolutions.co.uk.

