Long term absence dismissal was unfair – guidance for employers

An employee who had experienced ongoing back issues since 2017 and was signed off work became the subject of suspicion by his managers while on long-term sick leave.

The employer appointed a company to conduct surveillance, suspecting that the employee was exaggerating his condition in order to receive sick pay, which they believed might constitute gross misconduct.  Footage gathered by the external party evidenced that the employee had walked approximately three miles over a 90-minute period and that he had been able to bend down to examine the side of a car.  The employer accused the employee of dishonesty and dismissed him for misconduct.

The tribunal found that the employer had unfairly dismissed the employee.  It was found that the employee was deemed unfit by his GP and was not receiving sick pay during the surveillance period.  It was also established that the employee was disabled under the Equality Act.  The employee had previously requested a move to a less physically demanding role which existed, but the employer refused to make this adjustment. 

In a situation such as this the employer should have determined what reasonable adjustments would be appropriate – and should certainly have considered a role which was less physically demanding if it existed. 

The judge stated that the employer had not met the “burden of satisfying us that the decision to dismiss him was not because of his back condition”. As a result, the claim of direct discrimination in relation to his dismissal was upheld.  Also, claims for failure to make reasonable adjustments, disability discrimination and unfair dismissal were all successful. 

This case highlights the importance of following a rigorous process of absence management, including welfare meetings, engaging occupational health and considering reasonable adjustments. Should you wish to discuss issues relating to long term absence, please contact one of our CIPD-qualified consultants on 0800 9995 121.

Privacy Policy

 

 

Powered by The Logic of Eight - Creative Media