Tribunal rules that dismissal of injured employee was unfair

A warehouse employee who was accused of exaggerating his health problems and placed under surveillance, has won his claim of unfair dismissal. The employee was signed off with chronic back pain and while he was off sick, he received income protection benefits worth 70% of his salary through the company’s insurer.
 
However, after the company reviewed the employee’s social media and commissioned a private investigation, they concluded that the employee was not genuinely unfit for work. His benefit payments were stopped, and he was later dismissed.
 
The tribunal ruled that the dismissal was both unfair and amounted to disability discrimination.
The employee had been diagnosed with myofascial dysfunction of the lower spine, a condition recognised as a disability under the Equality Act 2010. An occupational health (OH) report recommended a phased return with lighter duties, supported by a risk assessment.
 
However, the employee’s condition worsened over the following months.After learning that the critical illness insurance claim had been approved, the employer saw footage on his social media and claimed that he was “moving freely.” The tribunal disagreed, saying he was only shifting weight from one foot to another, not dancing.
 
A private investigation firm produced footage showing the employee walking at a steady pace and walking through an airport with a wheeled suitcase. The tribunal noted he was medicated at the time and the bag appeared light, so the footage did not undermine his medical evidence.
 
The employee was told his insurance payments had stopped and was presented with three choices: resign, face a capability process likely leading to dismissal, or risk referral for alleged fraud.
He did not resign, and he was dismissed on the grounds of capability.  
 
The tribunal criticised the employee for cutting off insurance payments without waiting for a full investigation or sharing OH evidence with the insurer and concluded that the dismissal was unfair and amounted to disability discrimination.
 
Employers should avoid reaching their own conclusions about whether an employee is exaggerating symptoms and consider all reasonable options before dismissal. Should you require support to manage a capability situation please contact 121 HR Solutions on 0800 9995 121.

Privacy Policy

 

 

Powered by The Logic of Eight - Creative Media