Sales manager’s dismissal could have been justified if employer had followed fair procedure, tribunal rules

A senior sales manager could have been lawfully dismissed for misconduct had the company carried out a fair and impartial disciplinary process, an employment tribunal has found. The UK field sales manager, had worked remotely from Egypt for “several weeks” without authorisation, failed to comply with reasonable management instructions, and was not carrying out the central duties of his role. While the tribunal accepted there were “reasonable grounds” for believing the claimant had been guilty of misconduct, it held that flaws in the employer’s investigation and decision-making rendered the dismissal unfair.

The claimant’s role required him to spend at least four days a week in the field coaching, mentoring, and supporting his sales team. Concerns were raised during his trial period about the limited time he was spending with staff, and the period was extended. His line manager discovered that the claimant had been working from Egypt without taking annual leave. Laptop data indicated he had spent several weeks abroad, though the claimant disputed this. The tribunal accepted that he had worked remotely from Egypt, and that this undermined his ability to carry out his field-based duties.

Although the tribunal agreed that the claimant’s conduct could have amounted to gross misconduct, it found the way in which the employer handled the dismissal to be deeply flawed. The CEO initially dismissed the claimant on the spot before HR intervened and reinstated him pending investigation. What followed, however, was described as having only “the superficial appearance of fairness.”

The tribunal was particularly critical of the lack of impartiality and the failure to produce a clear investigation report. The HR business partner was found to have “orchestrated” the process with the outcome predetermined. When the claimant was dismissed again following a hearing chaired by a newly appointed manager, the tribunal said the decision was “a foregone conclusion”. Because of these procedural defects, the dismissal was held to be unfair, and he was awarded £61,419.50 in compensation.

What is frustrating for the employer in this case is that they could have reached a fair and lawful dismissal had the proper processes been followed. The employer may have strong grounds to dismiss for misconduct, but the decision will only stand up legally if supported by a robust, impartial procedure. That means gathering all relevant evidence, interviewing witnesses, giving the employee a genuine opportunity to respond, and ensuring independence between investigation, disciplinary, and appeal stages.

If you are interested in attending “Conducting Workplace Investigations” 121 HR Solutions is running this workshop in Montrose on 18th November and in Glasgow on 19th November. Contact events@121hrsolutions.co.uk for more information.

Privacy Policy

 

 

Powered by The Logic of Eight - Creative Media