Firefighter wins unfair dismissal claim due to flawed investigation
A firefighter accused of inappropriate physical contact with female colleagues was unfairly dismissed after an employment judge ruled that Gloucestershire Fire and Rescue Service (GFRS) carried out a deeply flawed disciplinary process.
The employment judge concluded that the investigation failed to meet the basic standards of fairness required in gross-misconduct cases.
The employee, who had nearly 20 years’ service, was suspended following complaints from two female firefighters. They alleged that he had touched colleagues inappropriately, allegedly slapping, grabbing and pulling at them and that he sometimes hugged and kissed staff at work.
However, the tribunal found that the employee was not told the specific allegations for weeks after being removed from duty, leaving him in significant distress. Occupational health records showed he experienced severe low mood during the suspension period. When interviewed roughly two months later the employee denied the allegations, claiming that what was being described fell within a long-standing culture of “banter” and physical joking among crews.
The judge criticised the investigation report, saying it resembled an untested collection of witness accounts rather than a balanced inquiry. She found no meaningful attempt to explore the broader workplace culture or test the reliability of the complaints.
The disciplinary hearing that followed lasted under two hours, the employee did not receive signed witness statements and was not provided with the opportunity to question those making accusations against him.
An appeal upheld the dismissal but the tribunal said that the appeal manager failed to properly review the process, did not consider pausing or returning the case for further investigation, and relied too heavily on previous findings without conducting his own rigorous assessment.
Overall, the tribunal concluded that GFRS relied almost entirely on unchallenged evidence from the two complainants and did not look for or test information that could support the employee’s case. Given the seriousness of the allegations, the judge said a much more robust investigation was required.
The dismissal was therefore ruled unfair. A separate hearing in December 2025 will decide whether the employee is reinstated or awarded compensation.
Where a dismissal could end someone’s career, employers are expected to exercise a higher level of procedural care and in this case the employee should have been advised of the allegations made against him and provided with the opportunity of questioning the statements of witnesses. Should you have any concerns about conducting a fair investigation, 121 HR Solutions has experience in managing such a process, fairly and objectively. Contact us on 0800 9995 121 for further information.

