Receptionist wins case following a breakdown of trust
A recent tribunal has ruled that a receptions form a veterinary practice was constructively unfairly dismissed after she resigned, because the company’s handling of disciplinary and grievance matters caused a breakdown in trust.
The main issue was a Facebook post when the employee shared another person’s post saying it was a sign to quit a job “when they don’t respect you”. She added no comment, did not name her employer and did not identify the company.
She received a final written warning for gross misconduct, but the company assessed her post against a new social media policy that was not yet in force. The tribunal found this made the disciplinary process fundamentally unfair.
The tribunal also found other workplace processes were unfair on a number of points including a dress code was vague and inconsistently applied; a warning was received for an equipment refrigeration mistake, while similar mistakes by colleagues had not resulted in written warnings; later disciplinary allegations were described as “at best tenuous”.
It appeared that the employer was “looking for reasons to discipline” her over any incident. She had raised a grievance during the disciplinary process which was mishandled. Her own line manager dealt with the grievance despite her objecting to this, there was no meaningful investigation, and her appeal was given inadequate preparation time. The tribunal said the process was effectively a “tick-box exercise” and breached the Acas Code of Practice.
The employee resigned saying her working conditions had become “untenable”. The judge concluded that the unfair final warning, further disciplinary action and poor grievance handling were the “last straw”, and the employee was entitled to believe the employment relationship had irretrievably broken down.
This case identifies that matters should be fully investigated and dealt with in accordance with relevant legislation. 121 HR Solutions is well place to support managers on process, contact us today to see how we can support your business, on 0800 9995 121.

