AI-written grievances: Why employers must look beyond the words
Artificial intelligence is changing the way employees raise workplace complaints, presenting new challenges for employers and HR professionals. But while the language of grievances may be changing, employers’ responsibilities remain much the same.
The growing use of generative AI tools such as ChatGPT means employees can now produce lengthy, professionally worded grievances in minutes. Complaints that might previously have been expressed in a few informal paragraphs can become detailed documents containing references to employment legislation, allegations of discrimination and demands for formal investigations.
For employers, this creates a new challenge: how should they respond when a grievance appears to have been drafted, or heavily influenced, by AI? The starting point is straightforward. An employee’s use of AI does not invalidate their grievance or make their concerns any less deserving of consideration.
Employers should focus on the substance of the complaint rather than how it was written. An unusually polished document, legalistic language or references to legislation do not necessarily mean the employee’s concerns are exaggerated or unfounded. Equally, AI-generated grievances can contain inaccuracies, irrelevant legal references or allegations that go beyond what the employee actually intended to raise. The key is to establish precisely what the employee is complaining about and what outcome they are seeking.
Where a grievance contains numerous allegations, employers should consider meeting with the employee to clarify the issues before launching a potentially wide-ranging investigation. This is particularly important where AI has transformed a relatively straightforward workplace concern into a complex document alleging multiple breaches of employment law.
Employers should avoid assuming that every legal reference is accurate or that every allegation requires a separate investigation. Instead, they should identify the underlying facts, distinguish specific complaints from general assertions and agree the scope of the grievance investigation. There is also a risk that employers may become dismissive of complaints they suspect have been AI-generated. That would be a mistake.
Employees may use AI because they lack confidence in their writing, struggle to articulate difficult experiences or simply want help presenting their concerns clearly. Challenging an employee over their use of AI could unnecessarily damage trust and, depending on the circumstances, create further employee relations difficulties.
Employers should ensure that managers and HR teams are equipped to recognise the potential limitations of AI-generated documents without allowing those concerns to influence the fairness of the grievance process.
The principles of a reasonable investigation, impartial decision-making and compliance with the ACAS Code of Practice continue to apply. Ultimately, AI may be changing how grievances are presented, but it does not change the fundamental question employers must answer: what happened, and what is a fair and reasonable response? The message for employers is clear: investigate the facts, not the technology used to describe them. Should you have a grievance to manage, contact 121 HR Solutions for support at enquiries@121hrsolutions.co.uk

